About

Evidence levels: how we label claims

Product pages and comparison tables on this site use five labels to show where a claim comes from. They are not quality scores. A product with a “Manufacturer claim only” label may be perfectly good; it just means nobody independent has checked that claim.

Label What it means Example
Our test We physically tested the item ourselves. The result is published with the date, method, a photo and its limits. A nickel spot test on a specific pair of earrings
Third-party certification An independent organization reviewed or tested the product against published criteria. National Eczema Association Seal of Acceptance; EPA Safer Choice; AAFA asthma & allergy friendly®; AHAM Verifide CADR
Published standard The claim refers to a standard or regulation you can look up, such as a material grade. We haven’t verified the individual product meets it. ASTM F136 titanium; EU nickel release limit
Manufacturer claim only Only the company says so. “Hypoallergenic”, “dermatologist tested”, “nickel-free” without documentation
Not verified The claim is vague, or we couldn’t find support for it. “Removes 99.9% of allergens” without test conditions

Rules we follow

  • No ratings we can’t back up. We don’t publish star ratings or scores out of 10.
  • “Our test” is reserved. As of today, we haven’t published any product tests, so you won’t see this label on product cards yet.
  • Dates on every check. Product claims change. Each card shows when we last checked it.
  • Certifications are shortlists, not guarantees. Any ingredient can cause a reaction in someone.